I said on a panel as a respondent today that my parents wanted me to go to Oxford. I did not. I spent my childhood and teenage years lurching from rebellion to riot, chaos to calamity, with one naive aim at heart - to be everything BUT like them. As I am now, 39, in a casual khaki suit, shaved head and piercings, with brogues and belts, and brains, perhaps I now stand in my own power, as it is, of course - my choice to step into these hallways 20 years after the ground work to come here was laid. A sabateur at 16, GCSE's good enough to keep me on track (my track) but not good enough to bring about Red Brick, Russell Group ideations of futures made and paved for me, not thinking of me, but thinking of reputation, projection. An Oxbridge daughter, law perhaps? I thought the bang average GCSE's would be enough to stem the trajectory, but a rather overzealous A-Level politics teacher, re-ignited the fire and direction of travel, at one parents evening at the grammar school "have we considered Oxbridge as options in our chosen 6?"
No, I pipe up, "I got a C in Maths and Business Studies, so I don't think it's an option,"
"Oh there are ways around that my dear, a strong personal statement works wonders," and just like that, my parents heart lit up in the vision that Oxford or Cambridge was back on.
So, PPE then? I was excelling at Politics, highest grades in the class, and duly the teacher pushing it forward, no. Not fucking PPE. Not Oxford. Not me. Not now. I barely tread water here in the parent pushing politics of catholic grammar, with priests and nuns and judgement. I want to be free.
I ended up in Abersystwyth and despite the trauam of incidents that occured during my University years, it was, by and large, the best time of my life, up to that point in my life. I could be me. Gay as the day is long, no more pretending, preening, projecting. The split personality and duality could rest a little and only present in holidays and post year 3 - although I did study politics in the end.
So imagine, today, seated at the front of a room, in Rhodes House, Rhodes bloody house, I dallied with the idea of being an Oxford girl when I came home from prison, I felt I could challenge myself to that level of academic horizon gazing and alas, the imposter syndrome and my mothers true voice echoed in my head - and I ended up applying to Leeds Beckett. I still to this day, don't know why, because even when asked yesterday "where do you study?" I said it with a whispher, that to say you study at the polytechnic whilst at the University of Oxford would some how cast you out. But I do whisper and perhaps my permanant baggage, because I've achieved great things at Beckett and met glorious allies who inspire, encourage, empower and innovate, collobarate and challenge me, academically, emotionally and professionally and if one must measure a University experience, surely it should be on those metrics, and not the colour of cap and gown - although I will say, Beckett could do with upping their game in the graduate day department.
Today was indeed a day of Complexity, for me on many levels, and I find the synergy and smirk as I type, because that's the purpose of Complexity Salon, to draw out one's intellect, conversation, positioning, politics, to a place of challenge, conversation that dips and dives into the depths of "more than talk," but as I say - the complexity for me, was being there in the first place.
I shared this in a conversation circle, and I realise I let my vulnerability show, which is an intersting concept given the lived experience positoning I was there to represent, amongst other things, other identities, we are of course, all by virtue, complex, and beings of lived experience, the fact that mine is of various cliches, matters not.
I vocalised the insecurity of being - that when we talk of lived experience, we are in danger of having the lived experience poster girls in the room, and that I'm accutely aware of that. Where I place myself, my time, my story, my vision, hopes, ethics and purpose. I've learned more often than not - the hard way, that one must be vigilant to the invitation of a lived experience representation, for fear of it being extractive, exploitatives, voyerisistic, or as its often the case - a pointless enterprise and a futile exercise in self flaggelation where one airs the nitty gritty of lives worst lived, to land in a room of admiration, indignation, celebration and alas, zero action. That, however, was not what today was about, and I knew that when I said yes. With enthusiasm might I add.
I will however admit, I had no idea what I was getting myself into as a "respondent," - by defininiton of course, I understood my role - to listen, learn, absorb, feel and respond. The joy of Complexity Salon is that there is no right, wrong, direction, directive, outcomes based repsonses required. It's reactive, it's human and it's based on instinct - at least I felt so. To that end, I spoke from the heart, head and sense of academic basis I have gathered through recent years; placed what I believe the pupose of "lived experience," to be, it's value, where positioned and I was thrilled to be challenged. As I say, often my words are met with warm smiles, teary eyes, nods to resilience and inspirational power in moving forward in ones life - all of which I'm grateful of of course, but today, challenged.
My position was one based on personal experience, that despite now having several decades of professional skills and employment history that justifies and quantifies my experience and relevance in rooms of power, policy and change - it's more often than not, my lived expereince of the justice system that opens the door. A door, which I find stays ajar a little longer, if the people in the boardrooms and the APPGs and more, here and see one of them. Now, I set my stall out today to say I despise the us and them narrative, and I do, it serves only to divide and segregate worlds trying to come together, to build bridges in, not out and yet we seem inept at doing so. With a media narrative and political pantomime that drives the us and them narrative incessantly, its impossible not to feel it everywhere, in everything. That said, my power in being seen as a "them," and when I say that I mean - educated, white privildge, posh voiced, well dressed, says the right thing, speaks the same language and plays the game of corporate, organisational, governmental nonsense, just as a lobbyist would running down the halls of Parliament. My point - lived experience is not enough to build mutual respsect, the power dynamic makes it impossible. The inability to recognise ones authority, relinquish ones authority, means there will always be a state of flux between those in power willing to relinquish the safety of their authority, to people not like them. With that comes risk, comes unknowns, comes the notion that perhaps it undermines their positioning. And lo' to speak the language of those who govern, to make change and make them listen, we must be seen as equals. Sometimes, the only way to do that, is not to be the angry woman with the sad story. It is to be the woman who can advocate and disseminate information in a way that is palatable, powerful and puruposeful. There was abject disagreement from some in my group that to dress to impress, and play pantomime professional was uneccesary and not a caveat or requirement for lived experience voices to be heard or valued. It's rare in life, at least in this lived experience life, to be challenged so directly - and from someone who fits the mould of the very power architype you are describing, but oh my, how refreshing, not to have a nodding dog and to have the fire of adversity and objection. That is entirely the point - only by disagreement and debate, may we move the dial forwards, or more accurately, balance the scales.
Complexity by name, and by nature. A searching exercise, with no agenda, outcome or preconcieved notion of having the answers. What a joy to step out of the echo chamber and instead in to the debating hall. And at Oxford none the less. It would appear I've come full circle.
I did however note, something I've been ruminating on for a while now. I need the tri-factor. I have my lived experience, fine, it's one point of the triangle, I have my professional skills, my education, my employment history, excellent, two prong of attack, but in reality, to elevate the conversation, and the instigation, investigation - I need the academic calibre. My academic written word is a source of pride, particularly as it has a clever nack of bringing my voice through the statistics, quotations, citations and data, it brings it alive. It's my passion. But I'm aware, as I type (on a train back up north, of course, when do I ever write unless commuting from a city or University these days?) I want and need what teenage Fran was so adamantly against - the red brick, russell group weight behind the work I do, to have the tri-factor, the triangle. The complete package. Then instead of justifiying lived experience, I can be more than that. It can become part of me, and not be a defining feature of my identity. If knowledge is power, I'm ready to claim mine.
No comments:
Post a Comment